login   |    register
Dragon Models [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEB SITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review
135
8.8cm Pak 43 Waffenträger
Ardelt-Rheinmetall 8.8cm Pak 43 Waffenträger
  • move

by: James Bella [ C5FLIES ]


Originally published on:
Armorama

introduction

The Year of the Waffenträger, or so it would seem. At least 20 of these weapon carrier variants were on paper with a small amount actually being built as prototypes and seeing action at war’s end, and as modelers we now have a good selection to choose from. Trumpeter has released a fair amount of these in the past year, and now Dragon has decided to jump on the bandwagon with the release of the Rheinmetall-Borsig weapons carrier packing an 88 Pak 43, which was built as a prototype. Running gear for this Waffenträger came from the Jagdpanzer "Hetzer" and the Praga motor was mounted at the right front.

Ardelt’s brainchild was a sound one, a way to transport various heavy guns and howitzers on a universal carrier, and also be able to fire the weapon while transporting. Protection against head-to-head encounters was minimal as these were not designed specifically for that purpose. First Lieutenant Ardelt lost his life in one of his Waffenträger’s while defending his home town of Eberswalde.

contents

Having built a few Waffenträgers already, and knowing what a simple design this vehicle had, I was very surprised to see how absolutely packed the Dragon box was…but then again this is a DML Smart Kit. After glancing at the parts diagram on the instructions, and seeing a heavy amount of ‘blued out not for use’ parts I realized the box would be just about as full after the kit was built. Needless to say, the spares box will be thankful. A mix of new and old sprues goes into the making of this kit:

• 15 grey styrene sprues
• Lower hull tub
• PE fret
• Decal sheet
• Instructions

Another surprise is how simplistic the instructions are, 2 ½ pages covering 10 steps. I realize this is a low part count kit, but it was still a shock to see Dragon instructions so uncluttered! The most obvious mistake in the instructions is that sprue B is marked sprue F and vice-versa on the parts diagram, although all appears to be correct in the actual construction steps.

Two paint/marking options are included…well, really only one as the second merely indicates the optional gun shield…Hillerleben, Germany 1944 with an overall dunkelgelb and some weird white marks on the lower hull. Decals consist of three Balkenkruz, black with white outline. Being a ‘paper panzer’, have fun with how you finish and mark this one.

the kit

When this was first announced I was quite excited about what Dragon would offer. New tooling on the Hetzer running gear? Hetzer Magic Tracks? Maybe a prelude to a future release of an up-to-date Hetzer? Let’s see:

First the newly tooled parts:
Sprue A holds the upper glacis with a separate grill (intake?), the track guards which are smooth, lower hull hatches, upper hull plate, casemate floor and some odds & ends.

Sprue B has the casemate walls, one piece barrel, well detailed multi piece muzzle brake, travel lock.

Sprue C, actually two sprue C’s although shown together on the parts diagram, contain the firewall, steering lever, nicely detailed suspension components, new equilibrators although not indicated in the instructions.

The lower hull is simple, as is the real one, and the front access hatches can be modeled open if desired to view the spartan interior.

Last of the new parts is the small PE fret providing a very nice radio rack, drivers hatches with non-working hinges, ammo holder and the optional shield for the main gun.
Hmmm…no new wheels?

Sprues from previous releases:
Sprue A: 38(t) running gear which only the return rollers are used.

Sprue C x 4: road wheels, idlers and track links from the Hetzer, all used except the suspension components.

Sprue d x 2: Hetzer sprockets.

Sprue D: the infamous (to those that build the 38(t) and its variants) engine/interior sprue. Here we use the radio, seat and steering brake.

Sprue D: this one from the Nashorn of which we use a few gun parts.

Sprue F: another large sprue from the Nashorn that we take the 5 shells from (although the instructions call for 6!). Oh well, we’ll have an empty space in the ammo rack to give it that ‘in use’ look.

Sprue P: more gun parts from the Jagdpanther

Sprue RB: another common DML sprue holding communication components.

Both the newly tooled sprues and most of the recycled sprues are beautifully molded to the present day DML standard of quality. The 38(t), Nashorn and Jagdpanther parts are very well done. Pin marks are virtually nonexistent as is flash. Weld beads look great on the casemate with the walls being molded to a believable scale ‘thin-ness’.

Unfortunately, in my opinion, DML dropped the ball by including the 16 year old Hetzer parts. The road wheels, a major focal point, are soft in detail with a plain inside face. Granted, the hull side of the wheels are difficult to view but is expected to be detailed in modern day kits. The idlers are fair, sprockets not too bad although mine experienced some ‘short shots’. The track links, unlike fine wine, did not get better with age.

As far as accuracy, hey…it’s a paper panzer! Still, sizing up to Doyle’s 1979 drawings the kit is well within scale. The only discrepancy’s I noted were on Doyle’s drawings the rearmost return roller was between the 2nd and 3rd wheels, whereas the DML kit has them between the 3rd and 4th. Also, the rear corner angle of the casemate seems to be more like the 5-wheel Waffenträger carrying the 88, than this 4 wheeled version. Small nitpicks.

conclusion

All in all, a decent kit except for the wheels/tracks. My high expectations were shot down by the outdated Hetzer parts. Personally, I’ll have to replace the road wheels and tracks with AM parts bringing the cost much higher than it needed to be. DML could have produced new tools for these parts (let the old Hetzer rest in peace already) and planned ahead for both more Waffenträger’s and a new Jagdpanzer. Recommended if you’re willing to spend time with the tracks or going the AM route.
SUMMARY
Highs: Mostly well detailed parts with a good amount of newly tooled. Tons left over for the spares box.
Lows: Including the ancient Hetzer road wheels and tracks. More markings would have been nice.
Verdict: Not a bad kit, but disappointing to me. Definitely needed to update the Hetzer parts.
  Scale: 1:35
  Mfg. ID: 6728
  Suggested Retail: $45.95
  Related Link: DragonUSA item page
  PUBLISHED: Jul 16, 2012
  NATIONALITY: Germany
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 86.44%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 86.19%

Our Thanks to Dragon USA!
This item was provided by them for the purpose of having it reviewed on this KitMaker Network site. If you would like your kit, book, or product reviewed, please contact us.
View Vendor Homepage  More Reviews  

About James Bella (c5flies)
FROM: CALIFORNIA, UNITED STATES

My main interest is 1/35 scale WWII armor, Axis and Allied, and will occasionally branch out into other areas. The builds I have done so far have been pretty much OOB, and considering what most newer kits include, that is usually more than enough for me. Even though my projects do not always end up ...

Copyright ©2017 text by James Bella [ C5FLIES ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of TankRat's. All rights reserved.


Reader Reviews
Do you own this item and want to review it? You can add your review of the item here. Please read the reader review instructions before posting.


Comments

Ola James Thanks for giving an insight in this kit. Allthough I like paper panzers and prototypes but I think I will let this one slip by my house silently. It is a bit lazy and not with good effect.
JUL 16, 2012 - 12:47 PM
You might want to ask yourself whether "Tons of leftover parts for my spares box" is a High or a Low. If they don't supply usable wheels for the model you're building, I know how I'd regard such "leftovers."
JUL 16, 2012 - 02:18 PM
Thanks guys Bob, yeah, I was pretty disappointed to find the Hetzer parts not newly tooled. DML most definitely would get their money's worth out of them with future releases of the other variants of the Waffentrager along with the Jagdpanzer. Then Cyber-Hobby could have made that special Hetzer for a white box kit...oh, well, it was a good dream while it lasted... Fred, the only 're-used' sprues I'm unhappy with are the Hetzer ones (which are the ones that most of the parts are used). All the others are excellent, especially for the spares box; extra 38(t) wheels, an engine that would look good in the back of a cargo truck, pretty much a full gun...so yeah, I'd consider that a high. As far as the Hetzer parts...they'll go in the 'other bin' Ordered some Hetzer wheels from LZ...it was a good excuse to check out some of Libor's stuff. Just need a set of friuls and I'll get building this one!
JUL 16, 2012 - 11:18 PM
I bought the kit and was disappointed by the geriatric Hetzer parts too. The rest of the kit is outstanding though, and I've gone Waffentrager groupie, buying all 5 antitank versions. If Dragon would spring for new tooling and Magic tracks, they could do the Hetzer, the Hetzer Starr, the Bergehetzer, the SiG33 Hetzer, the mortar Hetzer, the Hetzer 38D, the 38D with the Kugelblitz turret, the Hetzer PAW gun tank, the BMM 38t Katchen, and the Maresal M-05. Quite a crop of interesting and desirable vehicles that would all share half the sprues needed for the kit.
JUL 17, 2012 - 02:04 AM
Matt; I'm with you all the way! You ID'd quite the "Hetzer" wish-list and yes, I think DML would have potential for both many desired kits and lots of sales. I know I would be in line for at least a few, as the 38 and Hetzer stuff is pretty close to my modeling heart. Which makes this lazy old-stuff approach burn all the more. So... given as the running gear and tracks are geriatric but the rest of the kit is good, what could be a "reasonably-priced" builder's solution? Would it make sense, for example, to buy one of those new Academy Hetzers and use those wheels and tracks for a styrene fix-up? Is the Academy stuff a substantial improvement? If so, this could be cost-effective at the modest evilbay shipped price of ca $25. Even so, it leaves one a little unhappy to have to pay new Dragon kit prices AND have to buy substantial basic parts just to get a kit into nice shape. And we haven't got to the other AM which would usually be added for "pop factor". Bob
JUL 17, 2012 - 10:01 AM
DML supplies a complete Tatra 38(t) engine. Just wondering if it could be installed in the space provided beside the driver. Funny how Dragon supplies the part and the space but omits the small amount of engineering to mount the part in place. They also could have detailed the ammo panniers located under the rear platform - the two doors are moulded shut.
JUL 21, 2012 - 09:40 AM
I am building this kit now. You are correct, the tracks are really bad with lots of flash and sink holes. I was disappointed that it did not come with Magic Tracks, since it is a "Smart Kit"
AUG 15, 2012 - 03:52 PM
Hopefully you'll share some pictures when its done, Tim. I'm taking the easy way out with Friuls and LZ Models wheels
AUG 17, 2012 - 07:30 PM
Building this Kit right now, this review is pretty helpful, im willing to do a nice tank. thanks!
DEC 08, 2015 - 10:26 AM
Tip: Just hit enter to submit your reply!
   
What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move