login   |    register
Plus Model [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEB SITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

Built Review
135
US .30cal MG
U.S. MACHINE GUN .30 WATER COOLED
  • plusreview1

by: Bradley J [ HONEYCUT ]


Originally published on:
Armorama

Introduction
Having only seen similar weapons in injection plastic, I was intrigued to see just what quality was on offer from a resin and brass photo etch kit. Not being completely knowledgeable about the specific subject, I had a peruse to try and find some photographic evidence of the model on offer. It is simply labelled as a 'US MACHINE GUN .30 WATER COOLED', but knowing there were at least a couple of versions, I basically pinned this one down to being a M1917 version. (All photos I found did not show the carry handle on the barrel in place.)

The Kit
The kit comes in a cardboard box 4" X 3" and 1.5" deep and contains a small single page instruction sheet with a numbered 'exploded' diagram featuring assembly of the gun and tripod, and another alongside of the .30cal ammunition can assembly. The resin parts are cast in a dark grey and are attached to a couple of casting blocks which have their corresponding part numbers in place on the block below each part. Easy enough to follow (a magnifier may help though) A razor saw is recommended for removal from the blocks as there are some seriously small parts. I found myself constantly referring to the colour photograph of the assembled model on the front of the box in addition to the simple instructions while assembling

A brass photo etched fret is also included which has some exquisite detail including the parts to make 2 full ammunition cans, plus a length of rounds on a belt to simulate the rounds feeding into the breech out of the can, or to pack out a can with the lid open (or both!). It contains the cradle for the machine gun as well as the sight and carry handle arm. There is also a length of lead wire to simulate the hose from the water can, which is highly malleable and can be posed perfectly as needed.

Assembly
I started by removing and attaching the two largest parts of the gun, being the receiver and the barrel. There is a locating plug to fit the barrel in but I felt that a squarer as opposed to circular plug would help with alignment of the barrel, which had to constantly be checked as the superglue dried with the front sight vertical. To this you can show an open breech mechanism. The grip was added to the end of the receiver. The receiver rests on a neck piece which has a small pin to drop into the tripod fitting. As this is the main anchor point for the weight of the gun upon the tripod, I removed the small pin, drilled out the neck piece, and added a thicker and longer piece of sprue which gave much more support.

The cradle was assembled next. This was clearly the most frustrating part of the assembly, as there are two opposite sides to the cradle which has a resin 'bridging' piece at the rear, and has two holes to accommodate two pins on the neck piece. This is hard to do without a temporary jig holding the cradle sides square to each other, and to carefully fit the neck piece into place. A couple of resin levers added to the cradle and tripod, and we are nearly done with that assembly.

The tripod unfortunately was damaged on arrival, and I think this is due in part to the tripod being in one piece. It also had some warping to two of the legs. For the sake of the review I built it 'as is', but it could certainly benefit from some brass rod legs to replace the resin ones. One of the legs had snapped at the top fitting and was missing what would have been a hinge-like part to show the adjust-ability of the legs (and therefore the height of the machine gun above ground level). For photo purposes I didn't remove the tripod from its base because of fragility. There is some movement of the gun on the cradle, and of course it can rotate on top of the tripod.

I assembled one of the .30cal cans shown in an open position and the belt feeding into the mounted machine gun as per the box photo. The cans are amazing with embossed lettering on the sides of the cans and have fold lines to ensure clean lines when folding. But yet again there are some seriously small parts to add to the sides of the can and the lid also. The PE shortcoming is its inability to show what are clearly 3D items in anything but 2D? Namely the .30cal rounds. These would definitely benefit from other manufacturers 3D brass rounds, or even some plastic/resin versions.

The water can could do with drilling out the hole for the hose; same with the connection under the barrel to allow for a tight fit once the hose is in place.

Conclusion
A hard-fought journey to get this one completed. I feel I have a reasonable grasp of both resin and photo etch, but the way the kit combines the two left me speechless at times. Case in point, the carry handle on the barrel. Resin barrel, PE arm, resin handle, with no notches or locating points to mate the parts together. Same problem with PE cradle assembly and resin bridging part at the rear of the cradle. Pin to attach gun mount to tripod is too thin and short to support the guns' weight when mounted, and could do with replacing. The tripod would have been great to be height-adjustable, and the legs are quite brittle. With that said, once built it has tremendous detail and even with a coat of paint they would still stand out. I could see people buying this kit for the PE ammunition cans alone, as they are of exceptional quality!
SUMMARY
Highs: Detail is great on both photo etch and resin parts. Minimal flash to remove off parts.
Lows: Some poor assembly options between photo etch and resin parts. Instruction diagrams are printed quite small.
Verdict: A lovely kit once finished, but not for the faint-hearted during some assembly points. These can be overcome with some modellers ingenuity however.
Percentage Rating
75%
  Scale: 1:35
  Mfg. ID: 297
  Suggested Retail: $15.80 USD
  Related Link: 
  PUBLISHED: Jul 28, 2008
  NATIONALITY: United States
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 85.00%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 85.48%

Our Thanks to Plus Model!
This item was provided by them for the purpose of having it reviewed on this KitMaker Network site. If you would like your kit, book, or product reviewed, please contact us.

View This Item   View Vendor Homepage  More Reviews  

About Bradley J (HONEYCUT)
FROM: VICTORIA, AUSTRALIA

Copyright 2017 text by Bradley J [ HONEYCUT ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of TankRat's. All rights reserved.


Reader Reviews
Do you own this item and want to review it? You can add your review of the item here. Please read the reader review instructions before posting.


Comments

Brad, That was a pretty good review Good job. It looked like a fairly complex piece of a machine gun to put together. Plus model's did a great job to bring this 30 cal mg out by itself and your review covers one of the main components The 30 cal rounds are far better in plastic or resin.. Out of all the photo's on the Browning 30 CAL MG in publications I have never seen one with a carry handle . The down side is its molded onto the barrel. Maybe WW1 era? Thanks for this review I was tempted to get one but your review indicates there is a couple of issues . Cheers Michael
JUL 28, 2008 - 07:42 AM
Great review Bradley. Too bad Academy doesn't include this subject in their Machine Gun set. There is something good to be said about styrene kits. I have personally turned to Collector's Brass for my water cooled .30s, but the detail is nothing like that found on this kit. Somewhere "in-between" the three kits lies the answer... Mark L.
JUL 28, 2008 - 11:08 AM
Thanks lads. A couple of things... Michael, I have since seen a WWII photo (Ardennes Offensive?) with the handle in place Mark, the Academy US machine gun set is fantastic as you say, and Real model wouldn't have attempted this release if it was included in that set I reckon Kits can't be everything to everyone, but that said the tripod would possibly be made adjustable, or at least with separate legs so that the height can be set... I so wanted this kit to just fall together so I could give it a glowing endorsement, but that is what being objective is all about! Cheers Brad
JUL 31, 2008 - 09:48 AM
Just a little comment: The gun is actually a M1917A1 version (you can tell by the cradle design), which came after WW1, not during. I confirmed that looking at the browningmgs site.
JUN 11, 2009 - 03:15 PM
Tip: Just hit enter to submit your reply!
   
What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • plusreview1
  • plusreview3
  • plusreview2
  • plusreview5
  • plusreview4
  • plusreview6